What’s Wrong With Karma?
Tuesday, February 24th, 2009
So if Karma is an ethical system with right and wrong built into it, why might that not be a good thing?
The only answer I can see if karma is real is that someone set it up. Someone knew already what is good and what is harmful and arranged an ethically based system to punish and reward. Now to me, that means either what we do here is already known to be good or bad and we’re playing a pretty useless game or else whoever set it up IS NOT US!
If it’s the first option then it smacks of the Christian God - ‘now I know you’re going to fail this because I know it all, and I made you so i know you will be unable to resist the challenge, but don’t eat from that tree over there, because I love you but if you eat from it not only will it doom you both but every single human ever to be born.’
With such love, one doesn’t need an enemy.
If it is the second idea, that whoever set up the karma system is not us, then we seem to be the subjects of some kind of experiment, to not be here of our choosing and to be trying to find our way through a maze more complicated than any we have stuck a mouse into.
And given the religious backing for virtually all the karma principles, one must then suspect the whole foundation of the religions. If someone sets up a system within which you have to live, with no way for you to work out the details of the system without leaving it, and then imposes an unknown punishment/reward system on all within the system, surely we have to suspect the motives of whoever set it up?
Something seems wrong with the whole idea of karma and to be honest, I don’t see a way around it - unless karma simply doesn’t exist at all.
I’ve been exposed to a number of differing versions of the karma story. Some say it is about a life balancing thing – live a bad life now and you pay for it later. For others it can be almost instant where doing something bad now can cause an almost instant bad thing to bounce back at oneself.
If there is one subject that generates an amazing amount of dialogue, discussion and argument without ever apparently reaching a conclusion, it would be Spirituality. Not only do people disagree about what version is most appropriate to our lives, not only do we dispute or seek a wide variety of definitions of such subjects, but whether there is any such thing as spirit is something in which there is little agreement.
From Kirlian auras, through to electric fields, people have attempted to show that, if we are not just bodies living in a purely physical realm, our ‘spirit’ can be measured or shown to have reality within this cosmos. So far, as far as I know, nobody has yet managed to definitively show that the effects showing up in science have any relationship to what we term ‘spirit.’
I was in a discussion recently about Apathy. A person was saying that because of trauma, they were deep in apathy for a good part of the past few years. That raised my interest – I don’t know if shutting off because of pain or trauma can be defined as apathy.
I wrote this some time ago but I think it applies now…
Standing in front of a fire place on a cold night is a comfort – we watch the flames leap and cavort, we hold out hands to get warm and we relish the time spent with loved ones in such a room.
Most people have by now heard of the fires in Victoria, Australia. The blazes swept across bush and town, moving at incredible speed and burning hot enough to melt metal on the cars it consumed. The body count is nearly two hundred and there are still large areas the searchers have yet to enter, raising the possibility of even higher numbers of dead.
In our world it seems everything is becoming more and more geared towards safety. The government passes laws almost daily to curtail injury, to allow them to fine people who might put themselves in harm’s way.
The only way to advance, IMHO, is to rely on Self. It is what YOU understand about YOU that matters. Short of perfect telepathy, nobody can tell you about you. They can suggest things to try and point a direction to follow but it is you who must go there. Find your core, learn who you are and what you will or will not do and you are well on your way.
When a people are lost, when their society fails to provide needs that are basic to their lives, they look around for what will provide those needs. Our society has fallen a long way from an optimal path - we risk destroying our world in the name of greed and power over others - it is ironic because those seeking most the power over others have not yet begun the journey of power over self that would relieve them of the burden they are trying to relieve.
There are some problems with the bible. First, if we apply some basic psychology to the early days, it is clear God is at the least, schizophrenic and sadistic. At worst he could be psychotic. The way he creates Man, then sets them up to fail his test so he can kick them out is either very poorly explained or fits the Sadist role quite nicely. Why sadist? Because He has then visited the punishment on every human ever born – the bible makes that quite clear with it’s whole ‘born into sin’ dogma.