Education - Scanner or Diver?
Wednesday, March 18th, 2009
I was in a course years back where they divided humans into two categories - you will find that almost all the self-improvement courses do this - and theirs were Scanners and Divers. Scanners looked lightly on a lot of subjects, learning a little here and there, skimming across the breadth of human knowledge. Divers were the experts, the people who thoroughly delved into one or just a few subjects, learning the intricacies of their choices.
We went through exercises and questionnaires, discussion and lecture, and at the end, both the lecturer and I came to an agreement that I was a Diving Scanner. Now I know it was more about being lateral, but at the time it was an ‘Aha!’ moment.
The point is, none of this came out in the school system; I had teachers who tried with me, ones who thought I could make something of myself if only I’d put in the effort, but the system was wrong for me. I coasted through it. I never found the flame of learning that would ignite my passion. There was little or no attempt to adjust the curricula (and I came through in a time of change, so there were a few different ones) to suit the child and while I suffered less than many others from the system, it took me years to get over having gone through it.
Under Siege - Charlotte Thomson Iserbyt
Surprisingly perhaps, the stuff I found useful later on in life had to do with the rote learning, with the bits and pieces of factual stuff that got drummed into us. Being able to estimate, knowing how to spell and write properly, knowing the basics of math - all these have helped me along the way. The way-out theories on how to teach, on politically correct euphemisms, and the touchy-feely stuff designed to equalise boys and girls never did anything for my life. Knowing how to cut metal, use a lathe, layout a straight line and make a right angle all came in handy.
I find it difficult to simply accept statements like ‘This is how things are!’ without adequate proof. Even in Scientific American, I would read avidly the background, the hypotheses, the testing methodology and the results, but would find myself donning my sceptic mask when they tried to tell me what it all meant. Many times I would find I could think of alternates to their conclusions, often without putting a lot of effort into it.
While we’re on the subject of Education, I thought I’d indulge in a bit of a rant – hope you don’t mind too much.